Which ADU is Right for me? Ground-Up Construction vs. Garage Conversion

Dustin Edwards • April 5, 2024

ADUs are a great way to step into the real estate investment market. Typically, This is because they're cheaper to build than a brand-new house, especially if you’re converting a garage. This means you don't need to invest in a new property to gain a rental. The fact that an ADU is within your property can also help first-time investors manage it themselves. For experienced investors, ADUs can help maximize the income a property can generate.


Below is a list of elements to consider when building a brand-new ADU or converting your garage.


Budget

Your personal build budget is usually the primary factor in deciding which kind of ADU you’re going to build. For those with a tighter budget, a garage conversion will likely be preferable, as, on average, it can cost from $100,000 to $150,000. However, in these cases, you're limited to the dimensions of the original garage. 


While building a brand new ADU does allow for more creativity, you’re still limited by the maximum allowed size of 800 square feet in Long Beach, CA. For a ground-up build, the general average starts at $200,000 and can go as high as $400,000 or more, depending on layout, materials, and
ADU design.


Time

Building a brand new adu or converting a garage into an adu takes time. Both choices provide several pros and cons based on your needs. While converting an existing garage into an ADU may take less time, you’ll likely be limited to the original garage dimensions. However, you’d be able to list and render the ADU much quicker. Ground-up construction may take longer to complete. If you maximized the allowed proportions, you could have a higher rental rate.


Additionally, the permits to convert a garage are approved quicker than those for new construction. This can greatly affect the timeline of your build. If time is not an issue, you can opt for new construction and acquire permits and materials whenever possible.


Garage conversions from when you first talk with a designer can take anywhere from 9 to 14 months if everything moves smoothly. If your plan is to maximize the potential income from renting the ADU, then perhaps the 10 to 18-month time frame for a ground-up ADU build is acceptable. 


Space

Converting a garage may be more practical for homes with limited space than building a new ADU. However, you will sacrifice storage and parking space. Although there's no minimum lot size needed to build an ADU, ideally, you should maximize the available space to improve the rental income from the ADU. Naturally, accommodating a new construction ADU can be more straightforward if your home resides on a more considerable lot of land.


Potential Yield

The amount of time and money invested in your adu can greatly affect its yield. A garage conversion is usually limited in space because of the original building. A two-car garage is, on average, about 500 square feet, roughly the size of a studio or a single-bedroom apartment. Depending on the amenities provided in the rental, you could potentially earn $1,500 to $1,700. 


Using the allowed 800-square-foot layout for a new construction ADU, you can build a two-bedroom, two-bath home. With the larger building, you could potentially see $2,500 or more, once again depending on amenities and
incentives provided to the tenant. Before listing your ADU, remember to do a rental price analysis to ensure it is at a fair market price. This can greatly reduce vacancy periods.


Beginning your real estate journey can feel daunting, though it doesn't have to be the case. If you need more help deciding what kind of ADU is best suited for you or need help managing your ADU, we invite you to call us today at (562) 888-0247 or fill out our
Owner Application online.

Share this post

By Dustin Edwards May 17, 2025
Have you considered including utilities in your rent? Here are some of the most common utilities that help tenants see a greater value on renting your property
By Dustin Edwards May 8, 2025
Your property’s roof is its first line of defense from the sun, rain, and wind. Which means it will eventually wear out. Many landlords overlook this since a roof is generally designed to last twenty or so years, and they simply forget until the signs begin to show. Below, we’ve compiled a short list of five signs it’s time to replace your roof for when doing property inspections. Tenant Complaints When your roof has become damaged, your tenants will likely be the first to notice. When tenants report water stains on the walls and ceilings, it's a sign that you should inspect your roof. In severe cases, your tenant may notice water dripping from roof leaks. This moisture, if left unchecked, can lead to the growth of mold and mildew, which can be a health concern for your tenants. Some tenants simply move out, assuming the odors or recurring respiratory issues are caused by the rental and not just the roof. This leaves you with a vacancy to manage, and if you’re unable to find the leak during this period, the following tenant may have a negative experience as well. Many landlords have found it beneficial to have property inspections regularly in order to preserve both the property’s value and the tenant’s trust. Roof’s Age Even with the highest quality materials, a roof still has a shelf life. Most roofs in Long Beach, CA, use asphalt shingles, and these generally last around twenty to twenty-five years. Once they've passed this threshold, the faults begin to show themselves. A sagging roof line is a sign that your roof is due to be replaced, as it's a serious concern. It often indicates that moisture has entered the underlying decking and caused some structural damage. From ground level, you may not be able to notice these problems. However, during an inspection of the property, an experienced inspector should be able to notice soft spots or contours on the roof. These forms of damage often get worse over time. Coordinating these inspections and preventative maintenance can be difficult for landlords with an extensive portfolio, which is why many enlist help. Shingle Damage Damaged shingles are one of the most obvious signs that your roof is deteriorating. If you ever notice cracking, curling, or patches with missing shingles, the roof is no longer providing adequate protection to your property. Although you can buy time with spot repairs, if the entire roof shows signs of damage, it’s likely time to replace the roof. Aside from protecting your property, the roof affects your property’s curb appeal. A patchy and worn-out roof can drive down the rental appeal. Prospective tenants will easily be able to spot the differences between pictures taken in the listing when compared to the property in person. This can not only hurt your chances of filling a vacancy, but it can also hurt your reputation as a landlord. Granules in Gutters After heavy rainfall, it's a good idea to inspect your rain gutters. If you or your property manager notice large amounts of black or gray granules, it means your roof shingles are breaking down. These granules are critical for shedding water off the roof. Once the granules fall off the shingle, the shingle begins to degrade faster under the sun and elements. If you’re not sure how old your roof may be, Loss of granules can be a strong indicator that your roof is nearing the end of its lifespan. Regular gutter cleaning and roof inspections can help catch these problems early before they become expensive repairs . Increase in Utility Bills Your tenants complaining about their utility bills increasing or poor temperature control in the rental may not realize the roof is to blame. A failing roof can result in subpar insulation and ventilation. This can lead to higher heating and cooling bills for your tenant. This can be frustrating for your tenants while putting more strain on the HVAC system. This puts more wear and tear on your HVAC system. Being aware of the warning signs and being proactive can protect your rental property, maintain tenant satisfaction , and avoid emergency repairs. If you need help inspecting your roof or you need help managing your Beach City rental property, we invite you to call us today at (562) 888-0247 or complete our Owner Application online .
By Dustin Edwards April 30, 2025
Do you own multiple properties with sufficient
Show More