Which ADU is Right for me? Ground-Up Construction vs. Garage Conversion

Dustin Edwards • April 5, 2024

ADUs are a great way to step into the real estate investment market. Typically, This is because they're cheaper to build than a brand-new house, especially if you’re converting a garage. This means you don't need to invest in a new property to gain a rental. The fact that an ADU is within your property can also help first-time investors manage it themselves. For experienced investors, ADUs can help maximize the income a property can generate.


Below is a list of elements to consider when building a brand-new ADU or converting your garage.


Budget

Your personal build budget is usually the primary factor in deciding which kind of ADU you’re going to build. For those with a tighter budget, a garage conversion will likely be preferable, as, on average, it can cost from $100,000 to $150,000. However, in these cases, you're limited to the dimensions of the original garage. 


While building a brand new ADU does allow for more creativity, you’re still limited by the maximum allowed size of 800 square feet in Long Beach, CA. For a ground-up build, the general average starts at $200,000 and can go as high as $400,000 or more, depending on layout, materials, and
ADU design.


Time

Building a brand new adu or converting a garage into an adu takes time. Both choices provide several pros and cons based on your needs. While converting an existing garage into an ADU may take less time, you’ll likely be limited to the original garage dimensions. However, you’d be able to list and render the ADU much quicker. Ground-up construction may take longer to complete. If you maximized the allowed proportions, you could have a higher rental rate.


Additionally, the permits to convert a garage are approved quicker than those for new construction. This can greatly affect the timeline of your build. If time is not an issue, you can opt for new construction and acquire permits and materials whenever possible.


Garage conversions from when you first talk with a designer can take anywhere from 9 to 14 months if everything moves smoothly. If your plan is to maximize the potential income from renting the ADU, then perhaps the 10 to 18-month time frame for a ground-up ADU build is acceptable. 


Space

Converting a garage may be more practical for homes with limited space than building a new ADU. However, you will sacrifice storage and parking space. Although there's no minimum lot size needed to build an ADU, ideally, you should maximize the available space to improve the rental income from the ADU. Naturally, accommodating a new construction ADU can be more straightforward if your home resides on a more considerable lot of land.


Potential Yield

The amount of time and money invested in your adu can greatly affect its yield. A garage conversion is usually limited in space because of the original building. A two-car garage is, on average, about 500 square feet, roughly the size of a studio or a single-bedroom apartment. Depending on the amenities provided in the rental, you could potentially earn $1,500 to $1,700. 


Using the allowed 800-square-foot layout for a new construction ADU, you can build a two-bedroom, two-bath home. With the larger building, you could potentially see $2,500 or more, once again depending on amenities and
incentives provided to the tenant. Before listing your ADU, remember to do a rental price analysis to ensure it is at a fair market price. This can greatly reduce vacancy periods.


Beginning your real estate journey can feel daunting, though it doesn't have to be the case. If you need more help deciding what kind of ADU is best suited for you or need help managing your ADU, we invite you to call us today at (562) 888-0247 or fill out our
Owner Application online.

Share this post

By Dustin Edwards June 6, 2025
With the real estate market as competitive as it is, many landlords are looking into building an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) or Jr. ADU to improve their bottom line with additional monthly income. While this is a great way to earn more, you need to be sure you’re investing in the right upgrade to your property. Below are some of the key differences between ADUs and Jr. ADUs; this way, you can make the right decision for your property. Differences between Junior ADUs and ADUs On the surface, the primary difference between an ADU and a Jr. ADU is the square footage. However, there are many considerations for each type of ADU , significant differences include costs and build limitations. ADUs are generally seen as a larger and more versatile build when compared to a Jr. ADU. They can be built detached from the main home, converting an existing structure, most commonly the garage. In Long Beach, an ADU can be up to 800 square feet or 50% of the gross floor area of the primary dwelling, whichever is smaller. For reference, an 800 sqft living space can be arranged as a 2-bedroom 1-bath home, though with creative use of the space, many investors have been able to fit 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms comfortably. If listing the ADU for rent is the goal, this can produce a higher yield, though at the cost of a higher initial investment. Jr. ADU, on the other hand, can only be a maximum of 500 sqft and must be built attached to the existing single-family home. While you can build an entire new addition to accommodate the Jr. ADU, it's not uncommon for homeowners whose homes are bigger than they need to convert a bedroom into a Jr. ADU in order to have additional income . A Jr. ADU does still require an efficient kitchen. Bathrooms can be shared with the main house, though this can deter some prospective tenants. Additionally, the utilities are oftentimes shared with the main house, which can simplify installation, though it can complicate utility costs with your tenant. When an ADU is Right Being able to build a full ADU provides an entirely separate and private living space, which is more desirable to prospecting tenants. This is the preferred choice for most investors, especially those who have unused space in their property. By being built apart from the main house, an ADU may cause less disturbance to those living in the main house, whether that be yourself or another tenant. In Long Beach, CA. ADUs can’t be listed as short-term rentals on apps like Airbnb; that being said, an ADU can command more in rent because of the aforementioned features. If you’re looking for a long-term investment, ADUs increase your property’s value while generating a consistent cash flow. Finally, if you ever plan on selling your rental property, the additional ADU can improve the appeal of your property to future buyers. When a Jr. ADU is Right While a Jr. ADU doesn’t have the same potential as a full-sized ADU, Jr. ADUs are far more budget-friendly. These are a great option for investors who have limited funds. Since Jr. ADUs generally require less work to be done in less time, allowing you to begin making a return sooner. Finally, if your property doesn’t qualify for a full-sized ADU permit due to the size of the property lot, a Jr. ADU can be built primarily through interior work, which may only require reconfiguring existing interior space. Whether you choose a full-sized ADU or a Jr. ADU, the decision depends on more than just the size of the structure, you’ll have to manage filling the vacancy and managing the new tenant. If you need help choosing which ADU is right for you or you need help managing your Beach City rental property, we invite you to call us today at (562) 888-0247 or complete our Owner Application online .
By Dustin Edwards May 30, 2025
Summer is a great time of year where people enjoy a number of outdoor activities. Though for landlords, summer brings with it a list of maintenance items and preventative care for their properties. Below, we’ve gathered three of the most important maintenance items to do before summer starts. Service your HVAC System Southern California summers are getting hotter and hotter, if you want to maintain tenant satisfaction you’ll need to have the HVAC or any A/C or cooling system properly serviced . Filters should be cleaned or replaced, and the ductwork should be inspected. For rentals with window units or mini-split systems should also be thoroughly inspected as well for optimal cooling. Doing proactive maintenance can reduce the risk of the cooling system breaking down during peak usage while also improving the system’s efficiency. This can lower utility costs for your tenants while extending the lifespan of your cooling system, saving you money in the long run. Additionally, consider inspecting your window and door seals for leaks. If the seals are broken, it allows hot air into the living space, this increases the cost associated with cooling while adding more load to the HVAC or cooling system. While not directly a part of the HVAC system, ensuring there aren’t any breaks in the seals helps extend the lifespan of your cooling system which is beneficial to your bottom line. Inspect your Roof The condition of a roof is oftentimes ignored since they tend to last over twenty years, and some property owners may not even be sure when the roof was last replaced . A poorly conditioned roof is one of the primary ways for a rental property to drive up the costs of repairs and tenant complaints. A damaged roof can inefficiently insulate a home, making it harder to keep it cool. It can also lead to water leaks during rainfall, which can lead to water damage, stains, and mold growth. While summers tend to be dry, the coastal cities such as Long Beach may see unexpected shifts in weather, which can bring sudden rainstorms or increased humidity. Fixing a small roof leak is relatively inexpensive, however, leaving said leak to grow can result in an emergency repair can cost thousands especially if a tenant has already moved in. A thorough roof inspection is a great maintenance item to do during a vacancy period especially as this can result in a positive experience with new tenants. This can lead to a long term stay with many lease renewals. Check for Signs of Pests Pest infestations are one of the fastest ways to ruin a tenant’s stay while also damaging a landlord’s reputation. Pests such as ants, cockroaches, other bugs, and rodents are common in many beach cities, especially during the warmer seasons. Being in a city, you’ll likely never truly be rid of pests, though, even a single complaint about an excess of bugs or rodent droppings can lead to bad reviews online, service calls, and in severe cases, lease termination. These pests not only create an unwelcome environment for your tenants, but they can also cause real damage to your investment property. Cockroaches are known to damage small wiring in appliances, ants can ruin food and get in everything, while rodents can chew through walls, plumbing, and even electrical wiring. Landlords should schedule regular ppest inspectionsto check for early signs of pest activity before the hotter season begins. Much like everything in this article, preventative maintenance is significantly cheaper than an emergency call, in this case to an exterminator. If you want to keep your tenants happy and your property well taken care of, preventative maintenance is a must. If you’re unsure about the signs to look for when doing routine inspections or you need help managing your Beach City rental property, we invite you to call us today at (562) 888-0247 or complete our Owner Application online .
By Dustin Edwards May 27, 2025
A Solar Battery is an important party of a solar panel system. However, is it valuable for a rental property? Read on to discover.
Show More